Professional:Setting Up a Company While Employed, Filing After Resigning: Why None of the Seven Patents Was Retained
2026-11-19   |   发布于:赛立信

Employees develop technology while still on the payroll, then — immediately after resigning — file patent applications in the name of a company they set up themselves. Can that manoeuvre sidestep the former employer? In a series of patent ownership disputes over "laser printer motors" heard by the Guangzhou Intellectual Property Court, the answer was unequivocal: all seven utility model patents belong to the former employer.

The Facts: Core-Position Employees Set Up Companies While Employed and Filed Densely Around Their Departure

Company A manufactures laser printer motors and supporting electronic components. Xue and Chen were formerly employees of Company A's R&D technology department, holding core positions in R&D and production respectively. While still employed, the two set up Company Han and Company Jia, and subsequently filed seven utility model applications naming themselves as inventors and those two companies as patentees. Two of the patents were completed during their employment; the remaining five were completed within one year of their departure.

Company A argued that Xue and Chen had used core technical information and material and technical conditions they had access to at the company to file undisclosed technical information as patents, and sought confirmation that the seven patents belonged to Company A. Company Han and Company Jia argued in defence that the patents concerned entirely different fields and were unrelated, and that Company A had never carried out any patent-related R&D, so the inventions were not service inventions.

The Court's Reasoning: The Seven Patents Are a Single Whole, Closely Tied to the Employees' Duties

The Guangzhou Intellectual Property Court held that the issue was whether the inventions constituted service inventions. Under the Patent Law and its Implementing Regulations, an invention completed within one year after an employee leaves or is transferred from the original employer, and which relates to the job duties the employee undertook or the tasks assigned by that employer, is likewise a service invention.

The court did not accept the defence that the fields were different and unrelated. The judgment stated that the technical solutions of all seven patents form important constituent parts of a laser printer — either motor manufacturing and assembly components, or production equipment necessarily used in the assembly process. They are closely interrelated and should be assessed as a whole rather than in isolation. All of these solutions are closely related to Company A's main business.

On the specific question of relevance, the court focused on the correspondence between the technical field and the job duties. The evidence showed that the inventions were highly related to the technical fields and duties covered by Xue's and Chen's work at Company A, and that both had access to non-public information such as customer requirements, technical difficulties and corresponding solutions. The court therefore held that the seven patents were inventions completed in the course of performing the employer's tasks or mainly using the employer's material resources, and that the patent rights belonged to Company A.

After the first-instance judgment, Company Han and Company Jia appealed. The Guangdong High People's Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the original judgment.

The Judge's View: Within One Year of Departure, the Relevance Test Has Its Nuances

The presiding judge of the trial panel noted that the rules on service inventions are designed to balance the former employer's interests against the departing employee's freedom to choose employment and to innovate independently. The two limits — "within one year of departure" and "relevance" — both prevent an employee from using the former employer's information shortly after leaving to file patents and compete with it in innovation, and prevent departing employees from being bound for too long and unable to deploy their innovative capacity.

Notably, the court articulated a review standard in this case: for employees still in service, the threshold for finding relevance in a service invention should be somewhat more lenient than for those who have left. This distinction reflects the emphasis on the duty of loyalty during employment, while leaving reasonable room for departing employees' subsequent innovation.

Compliance Notes: The Boundary of a Service Invention Does Not Change Because "the Applicant Changed"

For R&D personnel, the technical information, customer requirements and problem solutions encountered during employment fall within the former employer's material and technical conditions. Filing a patent in the name of a self-established company does not alter the actual ownership of the invention. Technical results produced within one year of departure and related to the former job duties may equally be found to be service inventions.

For companies, the case points to two things. First, confidentiality management for core technical positions must operate alongside the service-invention system; relying on "employee self-discipline" is not enough to protect technical results. Second, when a departing employee is found to have filed related patents, the company should assert its rights promptly, so as to avoid evidence being lost or the ownership status being left unresolved for a long period. Who owns a patent does not depend on whose name appears on the application, but on the real connection between the invention and the job.

分享
赛立信集团总部

地址:广州市天河区体育东路116号财富广场东塔18楼

电话:020-22263200,020-22263284

传真:020-22263218

E-mail:smr@smr.com.cn



                
赛立信旗下网站
关注赛立信
免费咨询顾问一对一服务
请留下您的电话,我们的咨询顾问会在当天(工作时间)直接和您取得联系。